The Designers 3D CAD Shootout 1999

 

1999 Jury Grading Form

Teams work :

1. Floorplans

2. Elevations and Sections

3. Color Perspectives

4. Rendering

5. Animation

6. 3D Dimensional Modeling

7. 2D Construction Detail

8. Overall Design

Teams software :

9. Network Collaboration

10. Value

11. Ease of Use

12. Parametric Functions for Architects

13. Model Intelligence


Vignette Interviews :

1. Vignette A. Large Collaborative Project

2. Vignette B. Special Features

3. Vignette C. Parametrics

4. Vignette D Symbols

5. Vignette E. Stairs, Ramps & Elevators

6. Vignette F. Roof Design

 

* Best Overall Architectural CADD (for the Cup)

would be the total scores in all the categories (I), plus the Vignettes (II), plus the required drawings checklist (III)



This form in table format as printed


Every category and Vignette will be graded on a scale of 0 to 100 with 50 being "average"

0 - not done

10 - really really poor

20 - poor

30 - below average

40 - not quite as good

50 - average - good

60 - very good

70 - very very good

80 - extremely good

90 - outstanding

100 - perfect

Yes, Jury Graders can give scores, such as 63, and can give the same score to more than one Team.


In total there are 20 categories where there will be awards (gold, silver, bronze) - 13 categories, 6 vignettes, plus overall. Of those 8 have to do with the Team's performance that day, and 12 are about the design software that they are using that we can infer from their work and their presentations. Top scorer in the Overall wins the Architectural CADD Cup. Top scorer in Design wins the Anders Prize.